«Another great episode.
I think I've mentioned before about maintaining the overall quality in a hugely ambitious project like this...not only do you maintain it, but with each new episode, there's at least a half a dozen times where I say to myself 'wow, how did he do that' and I have to pause and rewind to watch again.
Very cool stuff sir.»
Enigma III Ep 3 Concensus
«Another great episode.
«Good: Very technically solid film. VOs were done nicely. I never really liked that "show" this resembles but I always liked it when they where up against that "enemy" the concesus resembles and it was just like that. Music was well selected. liked the Stereo panning. I dont think I need to mention the mods or effects.
BAD: A few of the sounds felt overly out of place, particulary the keybord clacking and the modem dialing. Overall I thought the sound fx could have used a little more volume especially during the combat. ( I know space is supposed to be silent but it makes for good action)
sidenote: I would have liked some more concensus screen time but I suspect as like that other "show" the will breiefly pop up from time to time then and graduallly build to an all out war.»
«Each time I watch one of your episode, I enjoy it, and this one as well. Each time I'm amazed to see this universe you create, we really believe we are in space, etc...
As always, modding as costume sets and props are great, and you sfx editing is not too much, but enough (I mean this is a good point, some are trying to do too much sfx and it doesn't look good, here's it's good)»
Great Episode once again.
Really enjoyed every part of this. BG music & sounds were well used.
Some of the vocal transmissions were a tad loud but great job done regardless.
Of course the visual side of things was outstanding. Really liked the Bridge & set dressings throughout. Also liked the Consensus voice, very cool stuff.
I was bummed out when it finished, would have liked to see whats about to happen.
The 26 mins just flew by for me.
Outstanding job Sir. Top notch.
«Review part 2 of 2
Overall, this was another great action packed episode with a huge range of stunning mods and you ended it really well. Makes me really want to see how this unfolds. I thought it was awesome that I can remember at least 4 instances where a character said "Indeed" . Oh yeah, and I love the fact that you spelt my name three different ways But I digress... Great work!
***** - 5 stars (if I could give it )»
«Review part 1 of 2
Nice. Great pacing to this one, went by very quickly for 25 mins. As always, the mods were just superb. The attention to detail is just outstanding. Love the costumes as well. The sound editing was excellent, great sound effect work over the intercoms, etc. In general the cast did a fantastic job (excluding myself ). Kwistufa is great as the Captain and K4's part was very well played as well. I thought the Concensus were very menacing. It'll be fun to see how this pans out
Like Strider said, I'd have liked to have seen more of the Concensus but I suppose the more mystery the better. Works well having them as an unknown opponent. Also, I thought in one or two shots you stayed on the same camera angle for a little too long. For example, the scene where it pans along the row of people working on computers with the captain, etc planning in the background and then stops at the end. I felt that could have switched to a closer view much sooner. The depth of field was done very well though
«Excellent work, flowed really well. Interesting character choices for belinda's crew. My only gripe is that the concesus lacked screentime, we saw them for a few shots but we never saw the atlas marines come up against them, only mentioned but maybe your keeping the screentime down for mystery effect I dunno. Either way can't wait to see what happens next.
«The consensus are absolutley shallow, maybe that was an artistic self homage on your part there. But yeah it was kind of bland and they didnt have any personalities at all.
I'm not really sure having your cast review this is a good idea, I mean they are hardly going to slam a production they lent their voices too.
Its just too much eye candy and not enough substance Uber.
1/5 from me, these star trek rips are getting old. Maybe you should try a new genre.»
«What I liked about this episode was that you took some time and paid needed attention to sound editing! Nothing was suddenly abrupt and that added to producing a higher quality Enigma. The sets, props, costumes, props, editing, pp, have taken this series beyond The Movies. The look and feel of the series is right where it should be. Belinda's motey crew was a bit of comic relief... Kwistufa is just nuts plain and simple. Thanks for the opportunity to be in this one.... a great experience. Super job!»
«Another adventure and another Enigma arises (pun intended)
Visually, another stunner (did notice a couple of those pesky misplaced fades generated by PP, though) with some great acting by the principals (especially EE as Tobias as mentioned below).
Unfortunately, not enough Concensus action in this one (though we know where it's heading...), but overall another corker.
Now get to work on Ep 4! »
The gorgeous visuals and interesting mods that always make Enigma visually fresh
A cast that's in the groove with their characters (EE was spot on with Tobias - it wasn't till the ending credits that I realized the part had been recast)
Unusually good use of music this time around - it really worked well
The Concensus, at this point, are like less-interesting Borg - effective adversaries, but without the "personality" - which may well be the intent.
Belinda (okay, more of a neutral - she was less irritating, but I'm still hoping for a bad end for her)
Overall, a very enjoyable ep, with an interesting mystery attached.»
- Related Videos